Hello dear
Welcome To Keystone Pizza
Keystone Pizza in Caldwell, ID offers a lunch buffet, featuring a variety of pizzas and a salad bar for $10. While not the best pizza in town, it is decent to good quality. Customers praise the friendly and helpful staff, as well as the nostalgic location. The pizza is loaded with meat, veggies, the right amount of sauce and cheese on a perfect crust. The breadsticks are a standout, according to reviewers. Despite the need for a building upgrade, the delicious food, excellent prices, and fantastic staff make Keystone Pizza a must-visit spot in Caldwell.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Keystone Pizza
Welcome to Keystone Pizza, a beloved pizza joint located in Caldwell, Idaho that offers a combination of mouthwatering pizzas and a welcoming atmosphere.
Keystone Pizza is a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike, offering a variety of options for both dine-in and takeout. With the convenience of delivery services and a full menu that includes everything from classic pepperoni to specialty pizzas loaded with fresh toppings, Keystone Pizza has something for every pizza lover.
Customers rave about the lunch buffet, where for just $10, you can enjoy an all-you-can-eat pizza and salad bar. The buffet offers a wide selection of pizzas, cheesy breadsticks, dipping sauce, and even decadent cinnamon breadsticks. While the quality of the pizza may not be the absolute best in town, it is certainly decent to good, especially considering the generous portions and affordable prices.
One reviewer mentioned that Keystone Pizza is their go-to spot for pizza in Caldwell, praising the loaded pizzas with just the right amount of sauce, cheese, and perfectly baked crusts. The friendly staff and quick service make dining at Keystone Pizza a pleasant experience for the whole family.
If you're in the mood for a nostalgic pizza experience with friendly service and delicious food, Keystone Pizza is the place to be. So, whether you're craving a classic pepperoni pizza or looking to try something new and unique, Keystone Pizza has you covered. Visit them at 207 S 9th Ave or give them a call at (208) 454-1700 to place your order today.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Lunch buffet is excellent deal. All you can eat pizza & salad bar for $10. If you're familiar with Idaho Pizza buffet, this is virtually identical. I even think the ranch dressing is the same. Now quality-wise, it is not going to be the best pizza around but it is decent to good pizza. They provide a wide variety along with cheesy breadsticks, dipping sauce, and cinnamon breadsticks. Salad bar has everything you need with two types of cheese and cut turkey squares. From other reviews it appears parking can be an issue but they have a ton of signs to inform customers so don't wander off premises and you won't have a problem. 4 stars but giving 5 to offset the dinkuses that give bad ratings for their own stupidity. ”
“ Good pizza, good ingredients. Loved the sauce too! Crust is a little thick for my liking so next time I'll try thin crust. Friendly and helpful staff. Nice nostalgic location. ”
“ Always our go-to for pizza in Caldwell. Excellent pizza...loaded with meat & veggies, just the right amount of sauce and cheese, perfect crusts. We always order to-go and the wait time is usually only 15-20 minutes. The building could use an upgrade, but the pizza is wonderful! ”
“ We come in from Dallas once a year to Visit, family took us to Keystone in Caldwell. Pizza was AMAZING best bread sticks ever! We loved it, place was great for the whole family. Prices are excellent food is delicious, staff is FANTSIC!! Kudos to Keystone for having such a great team and awesome establishment. See you next yr! ”